My friend Kyle came up with what I think is a genius idea, though I’m sure it’s been talked about before. College basketball has the ACC/Big 10 challenge and the Big 12/Pac 10 hardwood series. Why can’t college football do that? Kyle wants it to happen, and came up with a way that in can happen – all in one Saturday. The SEC would play the Big 12, the Big 10 takes on the Pac 10, the Big East tangles with the ACC, and even the smaller conferences get in on the action. Check out what he says…
I wanted to find out how conferences in major college football matched up with one another. Big 12 vs. SEC, Big Ten vs. Pac 10, ACC vs. Big East, C-USA vs. MAC, MWC vs. WAC, Sun Belt vs. everyone else…top to bottom. Basically, the best team from one conference plays the best team from another conference all the way to the worst playing the worst to see which conference gains bragging rights. I alternated East vs. West, North vs. South and Coastal vs. Atlantic where needed so it wasn’t unfair to one particular division.
This project was much harder than I originally anticipated. I think I worked on it for three hours, but it was very fun. It would appear that all of the conference match ups were fair as, according to my predictions, no conference beat another conference by more than two games. I need more of the season to occur to make some of these calls. Some of these teams are undefeated with two FCS opponents while some of them are 0-2 against Division 1 Powers. I randomized which teams got home games and which teams got road games. Then I realized it wouldn’t be fair (you probably won’t play the same team next year so you may have two or three straight years with this day as a road game). Some of these games were ridiculously close to call. Penn St. over USC was tough because Penn St. has played no one, and you know Pete Carroll would have the Trojans ready at Penn St. Ohio St. going across the country to Oregon was tough too because both teams are worse than originally anticipated (I know OSU played well against USC, but a four point home win against Navy?) In some of those games, I went with the home team by default. If you have problems with any of my picks, I have reasoning behind all of them and I’d love to hear your opinion. This format did produce some very intriguing games.
The teams without an opponent will inevitably play each other. This gave me the perfect opportunity to set up the annual event of Navy losing to Notre Dame (except for 2007). Everyone else gets a Sun Belt team. Fun Stuff.
Both Kyle and I made our picks for every game, and we listed them below. Here are a few points to remember:
- There is no room for subjectivity here. All of these games are determined strictly by 2008 season results using the formula 1v1, 2v2, ect., and our picks are based on the 2009 season’s teams.
- You will notice that, for example, in the SEC/Big 12 series, the #1 Big 12 South team played the #1 SEC East team. That means the #2 Big 12 South team plays the #2 SEC West team. This way it’s not just divisions playing divisions. That means next year the #1 Big 12 South team plays the #1 SEC West team and alternates from there.
- Home field is determined randomly, then alternates after that. For example, in the SEC/Big 12 series, the SEC East #1 team (Florida) got the home draw, meaning the SEC East teams #3 and #5 also get home, while #2, #4 and #6 are away. In the West, #2, #4 and #6 are home.
- This whole weekend would have to take place sometime in September as to not interrupt the conference season.
And now on to the games and picks!
SEC vs Big 12
Oklahoma at Florida
Kyle: Florida
Jaryd: Florida
Alabama at Missouri
Kyle: Alabama
Jaryd: Alabama
Texas at Mississippi
Kyle: Texas
Jaryd: Texas
Georgia at Nebraska
Kyle: Nebraska
Jaryd: Nebraska
Texas Tech at South Carolina
Kyle: Texas Tech
Jaryd: South Carolina
LSU at Kansas
Kyle: LSU
Jaryd: Kansas
Oklahoma State at Arkansas
Kyle: Oklahoma State
Jaryd: Oklahoma State
Vanderbilt at Colorado
Kyle: Vanderbilt
Jaryd: Vanderbilt
Baylor at Tennessee
Kyle: Tennessee
Jaryd: Tennessee
Auburn at Kansas State
Kyle: Auburn
Jaryd: Auburn
Texas A&M at Mississippi State
Kyle: Texas A&M
Jaryd: Texas A&M
Kentucky at Iowa State
Kyle: Kentucky
Jaryd: Kentucky
Results…
Kyle: SEC wins 7-5
Jaryd: SEC wins 7-5
Big Ten vs Pac 10
USC at Penn State
Kyle: Penn State
Jaryd Penn State
Ohio State at Oregon
Kyle: Ohio State
Jaryd: Ohio State
Oregon State at Michigan State
Kyle: Oregon State
Jaryd: Michigan State
Iowa at California
Kyle: California
Jaryd: California
Arizona at Northwestern
Kyle: Arizona
Jaryd: Arizona
Minnesota at Arizona State
Kyle: Arizona State
Jaryd: Minnesota
Stanford at Wisconsin
Kyle: Wisconsin
Jaryd: Wisconsin
Illinois at UCLA
Kyle: UCLA
Jaryd: UCLA
Washington State at Purdue
Kyle: Purdue
Jaryd: Purdue
Michigan at Washington
Kyle: Washington
Jaryd: Michigan
Results…
Kyle: Pac 10 wins 6-4
Jaryd: Big Ten wins 7-3
Big East vs ACC
Cincinnati at Virginia Tech
Kyle: Virginia Tech
Jaryd: Cincinnati
Florida State at Pittsburgh
Kyle: Florida State
Jaryd: Pittsburgh
West Virginia at Georgia Tech
Kyle: West Virginia
Jaryd: Georgia Tech
Boston College at Rutgers
Kyle: Rutgers
Jaryd: Rutgers
Connecticut at North Carolina
Kyle: North Carolina
Jaryd: North Carolina
Maryland at South Florida
Kyle: South Florida
Jaryd: South Florida
Louisville at Miami
Kyle: Miami
Jaryd: Miami
Wake Forest at Syracuse
Kyle: Wake Forest
Jaryd: Wake Forest
Results…
Kyle: ACC wins 5-3
Jaryd: Tied 4-4
Conference USA vs MAC
Ball State at Tulsa
Kyle: Tulsa
Jaryd: Tulsa
East Carolina at Buffalo
Kyle: East Carolina
Jaryd: East Carolina
Bowling Green at Rice
Kyle: Bowling Green
Jaryd: Rice
Southern Mississippi at Western Michigan
Kyle: Western Michigan
Jaryd: Western Michigan
Central Michigan at Houston
Kyle: Houston
Jaryd: Houston
Memphis at Temple
Kyle: Memphis
Jaryd: Memphis
Akron at UT-El Paso
Kyle: UT-El Paso
Jaryd: UT-El Paso
Marshall at Northern Illinois
Kyle: Northern Illinois
Jaryd: Northern Illinois
Eastern Michigan at Tulane
Kyle: Tulane
Jaryd: Tulane
UAB at Kent State
Kyle: UAB
Jaryd: UAB
Southern Methodist at Ohio
Kyle: Ohio
Jaryd: Ohio
Central Florida at Toledo
Kyle: Toledo
Jaryd: Toledo
Results…
Kyle: Conference USA wins 7-5
Jaryd: Conference USA wins 8-4
Mountain West vs WAC
Utah at Boise State
Kyle: Boise State
Jaryd: Boise State
Louisiana Tech at TCU
Kyle: TCU
Jaryd: TCU
BYU at Nevada
Kyle: BYU
Jaryd: BYU
Hawaii at Air Force
Kyle: Air Force
Jaryd: Air Force
Colorado State at Fresno State
Kyle: Fresno State
Jaryd: Fresno State
San Jose State at UNLV
Kyle: UNLV
Jaryd: UNLV
New Mexico at Utah State
Kyle: Utah State
Jaryd: Utah State
New Mexico State at Wyoming
Kyle: Wyoming
Jaryd: Wyoming
San Diego State at Idaho
Kyle: Idaho
Jaryd: Idaho
Results…
Kyle: Mountain West wins 5-4
Jaryd: Mountain West wins 5-4
Sun Belt, Independence and Leftovers
Navy at Notre Dame
Kyle: Notre Dame
Jaryd: Notre Dame
Troy at Indiana
Kyle: Indiana
Jaryd: Troy
Louisiana-Lafayette at Clemson
Kyle: Clemson
Jaryd: Clemson
Florida Atlantic at N.C. State
Kyle: N.C. State
Jaryd: N.C. State
Arkansas State at Virginia
Kyle: Arkansas State
Jaryd: Arkansas State
Florida International at Duke
Kyle: Florida International
Jaryd: Duke
Middle Tennessee State at Miami-Ohio
Kyle: Middle Tennessee State
Jaryd: Miami-Ohio
Louisiana-Monroe at Army
Kyle: Army
Jaryd: Army
Western Kentucky at North Texas
Kyle: North Texas
Jaryd: North Texas
Now what a weekend that would be!